I was going to introduce him, but he does well for himself.
For those of you that don’t know me, allow me a few sentences to introduce myself. I have been friends with Nathan since 1986, when my family moved in three houses down from Nathan’s family. He’s four months older than I am, a fact that I remind him of a little more pointedly each year. I graduated from Westfield High with Nathan, hold undergraduate degrees from the University of Louisiana and a master’s degree from Texas A&M, and am a traffic engineer by profession (licensed P.E. in the State of Texas). I live with my wife and our two children in Sugar Land, where we are parishioners at St. Laurence Catholic Church. Through the years, Nathan and I have remained close friends even as our families have grown.
When Nathan started this blog, I asked him to let me know if he ever wanted a guest blogger to help out in case he was running low on content or wanted to present a different perspective. While I tend to be quite opinionated and consider myself more than able in expressing said opinions, a combination of busyness and laziness prevents me from being up to the task of updating of a blog every day. So Nathan and I have set up a sort of win/win deal where he gets a day or three off every month and I get an outlet for uncorking a good rant every now and then.
Put our tax money where your mouth is, Planned Parenthood
Note: One of the favorite tactics of the “pro-choice” movement is to equate disagreement with their position as religious fanaticism. Because of the unique and awesome nature of our religious freedoms as compared to just about any nation in the history of humanity, Americans are rightfully wary of the notion that anyone should be allowed to forcefully impose their religious beliefs on another. If the abortion lobby can convince Americans that the pro-life movement is simply a bunch of wild-eyed, Bible-thumping, fire-and-brimstone-preaching purveyors of theocracy who wish to keep all women “barefoot and pregnant” or something, then our arguments can be dismissed as the mere ravings of lunatics unworthy of being addressed. This same tactic can be seen in the branding of any criticism of President Barack Obama’s policies as “racism.” If you’re nothing but a Jim Crow racist, then anything you say has no merit, and can thus be dismissed without being addressed. Simply put, it’s nothing more than intellectually dishonest form of avoiding debate, equivalent to saying, “Shut up.”
Because of this, I never, ever use religious arguments in stating my pro-life principles – not because I don’t believe the religious arguments, but because avoiding them voids that abortionist line of attack. The irony of all this is that pro-life principles do not require the buttressing of Christian theology. Not only does support for abortion have no basis in theology, it has no basis in science or logic as well. One can combat any abortionist argument without “putting your rosaries on their ovaries” or some other such fit-for-a-bumper-sticker nonsense. The sole “ethical” argument to be made is that we shouldn’t kill other innocents, a notion that is far from confined to Christianity, or even religion as a whole. With those long-winded programming notes out of the way, on to our feature presentation…
Last week’s tempest in a pink t-shirt has once again brought to the forefront the issue of how Planned Parenthood, the largest abortion provider in the United States, allocates funds received from donors, voluntary or involuntary (i.e. taxpayers and Susan G. Komen donors, amongst others), most of whom have the nerve to expect that their money not be used to murder unborn children. This is not an extremist position in the U.S., as various polls taken at the height of the national health care reform debate in late 2009 show that opposition to taxpayer dollars being used to fund abortions generally rates a cool 60 percent.
Planned Parenthood and its defenders insist that tax money is specifically earmarked for gynecological services for women who could otherwise not afford them. Similarly, it is argued that donations from breast cancer charities such as Susan G. Komen are only used for breast cancer screening for low-income women. Even if this funding purposing is the 100 percent iron-clad intent of Planned Parenthood executives, it is simply not possible in practice. Money is fungible, it flows freely from one purpose to another.
If I make a $1,000 donation to Planned Parenthood, I can tell them I want it to go specifically to paint the lines in the parking lot at their new abattoir on the Gulf Freeway in Houston. Boom. They paint the lines. Done. Shiny happy people holding hands.
What happens if I don’t give Planned Parenthood that money? They still need to paint the lines. Can you imagine an un-striped parking lot with all those women drivers? I kid, I kid….sort of. Anyway, the $1,000 it costs to paint those lines has to come from somewhere else, somewhere from their overall revenues. That $1,000 is now spent on striping the parking lot rather than on the services that they provide, including abortions. Every dollar they receive for striping the parking lot is a dollar that is freed up to provide services, including the 330,000 abortions they performed in 2010.
Similarly, every tax dollar or charity dollar that Planned Parenthood receives for other women’s health services is a dollar freed up from their other revenue sources to provide abortions. Honestly, one would have to be willfully obtuse not to understand this.
Now, one could argue that without those outside sources of revenue, Planned Parenthood would have to cease offering non-abortion women’s health services. While I don’t agree with this, rather than get into their financial statements and argue it, I will concede that point for the sake of this discussion. I will also concede that given the screwed up funding mechanisms in the U.S. health care system (a topic for another post), Americans as a whole deem non-abortion women’s health care services as a worthy recipient of largess from the federal government money tree.
In spite of what the abortionists claim, those that seek de-funding of Planned Parenthood do not want women to die on examination tables, as Rep. Nancy Peolsi put it, in keeping with the Democrat Party’s long-cherished commitment to civility. If Planned Parenthood loses federal tax dollars, what is going to happen to those women who benefitted from Planned Parenthood’s use of those dollars?
We’re talking about the federal government money tree here, where money never goes un-spent. Surely, SURELY, we can find a way to help those women. If only there was a network of health care facilities that provided similar women’s health care services! Oh, wait….
Contrary to what Planned Parenthood would have you believe, they did not invent the pap smear, the cervical exam, the mammogram, or the manual breast exam (I’m pretty sure we have a drunk college kid at a fraternity party to thank for that last one). In addition to the thousands of providers of these services already available to low-income women, other women’s health care providers could accept money that used to go to Planned Parenthood in order to serve low-income women (and without the hefty dumpster costs). Crazy talk, right?
And Planned Parenthood, have I got a deal for you! You can even keep receiving those federal tax dollars to provide those services yourself!
But there’s a catch.
Spin off your abortion business into a completely separate entity. No shared facilities. No money passing between the two organizations. You pulled in approximately $164 million from abortions in 2009, about 15 percent of your total revenues according to your annual report. Since you claim that abortions are such a small part of what you do, surely Abortions R Us will be able to make a go of it with 164 mill. In return, all the other services you provide, which you trumpet as your raison d’être, continue to receive federal and charity dollars, not to mention the numerous religious charities who will suddenly find you attractive once you’ve washed off that dead baby smell.
Until such an action is taken, you are always going to have us extremist women-haters at your door, demanding that our money stop being used to fund the slaughter of innocents. Because, all protestations to the contrary, that’s what you’re doing.